Trucking Company Can’t Be Sued For Trucker’s Death, Says Court

Trucking Company Can’t Be Sued For Trucker’s Death, Says Court

The Texas Supreme Court has ruled in a lawsuit that the family of a deceased truck driver can’t sue the trucking company where he was employed. The driver died after being coerced by the company to overwork, resulting in fatigue. He died when he fell asleep behind the wheel and ran into the accident.

The defendant in the case has been identified as Mo-Vac Services Co. Inc. Fabian Escobedo was a driver with the company. He was riding a company truck to a location in Dilley Texas when he fell asleep. The truck ran off the road, struck a pole and overturned. Escobedo was trapped inside the vehicle and died due to asphyxiation. The incident occurred several years ago on May 30, 2012.

A lawsuit had been brought against the company by Escobedo’s parents and sister. However, the Texas Supreme Court has now ruled that Mo-Vac is protected from the lawsuit due to the provisions of the Texas workers compensation system. The workers’ comp insurance effectively shields employees from being sued by workers who may become injured or die during work.

A key exemption to this protection is when the deliberate and intentional negligence of the employer can be proved. This is what the present lawsuit hinged upon. Plaintiffs argued that Mo-Vac was deliberately violating Hours of Service requirements by asking the drivers to falsify their log books while working longer hours. This was testified by several co-workers of Escobedo who also appeared in the court.

However, Texas Supreme Court ruled that despite substantial evidence of Mo-Vac violating Hours of Service requirements, it can’t be shown that this violation directly led to the driver’s death. For this reason, the Court has also refused to award any exemplary damages to the survivors of Escobedo, ruling that the family is entitled only to workers’ compensation benefits. If you are injured at work, you should contact our Beaumont workers compensation attorneys.

Source: https://cdllife.com/2020/court-family-cant-sue-over-truckers-death-due-to-fatigue-after-being-forced-to-work-17-hour-days/

search

our offices

  • Beaumont Office

    215 Orleans St.
    Beaumont, TX 77701

  • Houston Office

    300 Fannin St.
    Suite 300
    Houston, TX 77002

  • Burbank Office

    4111 W. Alameda Avenue
    Suite 611
    Burbank, California 91505

  • Denver Office

    3801 E. Florida Ave.
    Suite 905
    Denver, CO 80210-2500

  • Philadelphia Office

    1500 Walnut Street
    Suite 2000
    Philadelphia, PA 19102

FROM THE BLOG

Texas A&M donors’ lawsuit against 12th Man Foundation over Kyle Field seats and parking to proceed

By David Barron, Correspondent A Brazos County state district judge has cleared the way for a long-delayed trial showdown between a group of disillusioned Texas A&M donors and the A&M-affiliated 12th Man Foundation, stemming from a decade-old dispute over seating and parking rights at Kyle Field. State District Judge George Jerrell Wise on Wednesday signed an order denying a summary…

Lawsuit Against Texas A&M Aggies 12th Man Foundation Moves Forward

A legal showdown between former Texas A&M donors and the 12th Man Foundation will proceed at last. A Brazos County judge has ruled that a lawsuit between former Texas A&M Aggies donors and the 12th Man Foundation will move forward, David Barron of the Houston Chronicle reports. On Wednesday, State District Judge George Jerrell Wise…

Texas A&M donors’ lawsuit against 12th Man Foundation over seating, parking dispute cleared for trial

A group of Texas A&M donors will finally get their day in court for a dispute against the 12th Man Foundation over parking and seating at Kyle Field. According to the Houston Chronicle, a judge in Brazos County last week denied a summary judgment motion from the 12th Man Foundation, which sought to dismiss the…